Dr Ajay Khemariya explores the evolving politics of global protest movements, questioning whether organised campaigns and digital strategies—used in Bangladesh’s 2024 crisis—risk destabilising democracies like India. While protests can legitimately push for accountability, concerns arise about external coordination, opaque funding, and the 'Red-Green' ideological alliances. His commentary emphasizes transparency, evidence-based scrutiny, and constitutional restraints to protect institutional integrity amid rising digital activism.
Bhopal, October 19, 2026
From Bangladesh to India, organised protests, digital campaigns and international advocacy networks have raised fresh questions about political mobilisation. Writing in Swadesh Saptak, political commentator Dr Ajay Khemariya examines these developments and their possible implications for democratic institutions.
Can organised street protests influence the future of an elected government? How do social media campaigns and international advocacy groups shape public opinion? And where should democracies draw the line between legitimate political dissent and attempts to destabilise elected institutions? These questions have gained importance amid continuing political confrontation over electoral reforms and the functioning of constitutional institutions in India.
In his commentary published in Swadesh Saptak, the weekly publication of the Swadesh Group, Dr Khemariya raises concerns about organised protest networks, ideological alliances and possible foreign influence in domestic political movements. His analysis explores how modern political campaigns increasingly rely on digital communication, coordinated demonstrations and international publicity. He argues that these developments deserve closer examination, particularly when political protests begin challenging established institutions.
A major concern in Dr Khemariya's analysis is the use of what are commonly described as regime-change toolkits. Regime change broadly refers to the replacement of an existing government. In a democracy, governments ordinarily change through elections and constitutional procedures. However, sustained public mobilisation can also create political pressure outside the normal electoral cycle.
History offers several examples of mass movements influencing political transitions. Some have emerged from genuine public grievances, while others have raised questions about political coordination, external support and competing interests.
A protest toolkit is essentially a collection of resources used to organise campaigns. It may contain social media messages, protest schedules, legal information, communication strategies and suggestions for public participation. Such methods are widely used in peaceful civic movements. Their use does not, by itself, indicate unlawful activity or foreign interference.
The concern raised by Dr Khemariya is whether organised political interests could use these methods to pursue objectives that are not always publicly disclosed. He believes greater transparency is necessary when political campaigns involve multiple organisations, coordinated messaging and international advocacy.
Another important aspect of the commentary is the so-called Red-Green alliance. The expression is sometimes used in political discourse to describe cooperation between sections of the ideological Left and Islamist political movements.
Dr Khemariya examines how groups with different ideological backgrounds may find common ground when they share a political objective. Such cooperation can influence public campaigns, particularly when domestic political issues attract international attention.
However, the expression is a broad political label. It does not establish the existence of a single international organisation or a coordinated network operating across countries.
Political cooperation is also not inherently unlawful. Any allegation involving covert funding, illegal coordination or attempts to undermine democratic institutions requires credible and independently verifiable evidence. This distinction is important because political alliances, protest movements and ideological disagreements are normal features of democratic life.
The political developments in Bangladesh during 2024 provide an important international reference in the commentary. The country witnessed widespread student-led protests that initially focused on government job quotas. The movement subsequently expanded into a broader confrontation with the government. As demonstrations intensified, Bangladesh entered a period of political uncertainty. Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina eventually left office in August 2024.
The developments there illustrated how quickly public dissatisfaction can grow into a nationwide political movement. Digital platforms played an important role in spreading information, organising demonstrations and drawing international attention to events. However, Bangladesh's political crisis also reflected domestic grievances, allegations of repression and growing public anger. The use of digital mobilisation or coordinated demonstrations does not, on its own, establish that a protest movement was externally directed.
Dr Khemariya's wider argument invites examination of how such movements develop, who supports them and whether political interests beyond the immediate public grievances become involved. These questions are relevant to political developments in several countries, although each movement must be understood in its own historical and social context.
The discussion has particular relevance in India, where the BJP and Opposition parties have taken sharply different positions on recent protests over electoral reforms. The BJP has accused sections of the Opposition of attempting to weaken public confidence in constitutional institutions. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh has also criticised the Congress and its allies over their protest strategy. According to media reports, he questioned whether the Opposition was drawing inspiration from political developments in Bangladesh.
The Congress and other Opposition parties have rejected such accusations. They maintain that their demonstrations seek greater electoral transparency, accountability and public confidence in the democratic process.
The disagreement reflects a wider political debate over the role of street protests in a parliamentary democracy. For the government and its supporters, the concern is that sustained campaigns against constitutional bodies may weaken public trust in institutions.
For the Opposition, peaceful demonstrations remain a legitimate means of questioning government decisions and demanding institutional accountability. Both positions must be examined within India's constitutional framework.
Dr Khemariya approaches the issue primarily from the perspective of institutional stability. His commentary argues that political disagreements should ultimately be addressed through democratic and constitutional procedures.
Another issue examined in the commentary concerns international foundations, advocacy organisations and their possible influence on domestic political campaigns. Global organisations frequently support education, research, human rights, environmental protection and civic participation. Such activities are not inherently unlawful. International cooperation also plays an important role in democratic societies.
However, questions about financial transparency and organisational relationships become significant when allegations of political interference arise.
India has legal provisions regulating foreign contributions to specified organisations and activities. The Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act provides a framework for monitoring foreign funding and its permitted use. The existence of foreign funding, however, cannot automatically be treated as evidence of political interference. Similarly, common campaign methods, shared political positions or international publicity do not establish unlawful coordination. Dr Khemariya's concerns underline the importance of examining funding arrangements and organisational activities through established legal and regulatory mechanisms.
India's Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) and the right to assemble peaceably and without arms under Article 19(1)(b). These freedoms are subject to constitutionally permitted reasonable restrictions. Citizens have the right to question government policies, organise peaceful demonstrations and demand political accountability.
Indeed, public movements have played an important role in India's democratic and political history. At the same time, violence, intimidation and unlawful interference with public institutions cannot be justified in the name of political dissent.
The challenge lies in distinguishing legitimate public grievances from allegations that organised interests may be exploiting those grievances for undisclosed political purposes. Such distinctions cannot rest merely on political accusations or ideological differences. They require evidence, transparent investigation and adherence to due process.
The wider significance of Dr Khemariya's commentary lies in the changing nature of political mobilisation. Digital platforms have made public campaigns faster, more visible and capable of reaching audiences across national boundaries. A local demonstration can attract international attention within hours. Political messages can spread rapidly, while competing narratives may influence how events are understood. These developments create opportunities for democratic participation. They also bring challenges involving misinformation, opaque funding and coordinated influence campaigns.
Dr Khemariya's analysis raises questions about how democratic institutions should respond to these changes without restricting legitimate political expression. India's democratic framework provides space for political disagreement, peaceful protest and changes of government through constitutional means.
The larger question is not whether citizens should protest, but how democratic societies can protect the right to dissent while ensuring that political mobilisation remains transparent, peaceful and accountable.
Protecting institutional stability and safeguarding civil liberties are not necessarily competing objectives. Both are essential to public confidence in democracy. The debate examined by Dr Khemariya ultimately highlights the importance of constitutional safeguards, responsible political conduct and credible evidence when allegations of organised interference enter public discourse.